A consensus is forming that Labour’s policies at the election were popular – it is just that there were too many of them; or that the party couldn’t be trusted to deliver them; or that Jeremy Corbyn was unpopular; or that Brexit was too much of a distraction. It is possible, though, that Labour’s “radical” economic programme wasn’t actually popular when it came to the test. People say they want to nationalise the railways and abolish student fees but when presented with them as a prospectus for an alternative government, they voted against it. 

I wonder if this means something more fundamental is going on: that opposing “capitalism” is fashionable, but, when it came to it, Corbyn’s Labour had no idea whether to replace it, and if so with what, or to reform it, and if so in what way. It is possible that this election was a battle of ideas – a rare thing in pragmatic British politics – and that, despite Corbyn’s vainglorious claim to have “won the arguments”, it was a battle that Labour comprehensively lost.

People don’t vote for big ideas, but sometimes they vote for leaders who believe in big ideas. Capitalism is a big idea, and Boris Johnson and the Conservative Party believe in it. But anti-capitalism isn’t a big idea, unless the alternative is defined. Corbyn never got beyond protesting against the iniquities of the market, while John McDonnell, his shadow chancellor, who was often portrayed as a serious ideologue, never set out what Marxists would call an analysis of the economy, let alone an alternative to the status quo. 

Sharing the full story, not just the headlines


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Trump cites game show host on pandemic while undercutting health officials and questioning their expertise

With a series of tweets, impromptu interviews and unscripted remarks, President Trump has increasingly undermined the public health message of his own government, adding a sense of confusion to what has been a disjointed and ineffective response to the coronavirus…

2020 Sunday Trail Markers: Where the candidates stand on guns

Here’s what you need to know in politics this week… Where the candidates stand on guns 2020 Dems angered by “another mass shooting,” decry congressional inaction Dems descend on Iowa state fair This week’s schedule WHERE THE CANDIDATES STAND ON…

‘Overrun by angry mobs’: South Dakota Gov. Noem calls out Democratic-run cities

South Dakota Gov. Kristi Noem opened Night 3 of the Republican National Convention on Wednesday by charging that America’s “founding principles are under attack” and declaring that “Democrat-run cities across this country are being overrun by violent mobs.” “The violence…

Fauci and Birx worked together at the dawn of the AIDS crisis. Thirty-seven years later, they are partners in fighting the coronavirus.

Anthony Fauci and Deborah Birx walked side-by-side in the 1980s on hospital rounds, watching young men die of a mysterious disease that had no cure. The disease was so deadly that when Birx lost a large amount of blood giving…